All cases

New York City

New York City CityTime payroll project

New York City’s payroll-system project grew far beyond its original contract, partly through a proven fraud scheme. Leaders were sentenced, and the city recovered substantial money.

Project cost by December 2010Over $620 million
Evidence finding

Criminal convictions and recoveries

Source documents6View sources ↗

Ask Impact Analyst

Ask about the numbers or evidence. Keep the conversation going with follow-up questions.

By sending, you agree to share your question and this case’s notes with Google Gemini and save the conversation privately for review. Privacy

Impact Analyst

New York City CityTime payroll project

What would you like to understand?

Answers use this case’s sources and notes. They do not search the web.

AI answers can be wrong. Check the sources. Enter to send; Shift+Enter for a new line.

Privacy and sharing

By sending, you agree that Google Gemini can process your question and this case’s public notes. We save the conversation privately for review. Leave out private personal details.

Nothing is published automatically. Keep the saved reference if you want to request deletion. Read the privacy policy.

What was the money for?

Build New York City’s CityTime payroll system.

Amount discussed in this caseOver $620 million project cost

More than $620 million was the project cost by December 2010, compared with an original contract of about $73 million in 2000. The entire project cost was not stolen.

Exact amount, time period and source wording

Project cost by December 2010, partly driven by fraud; not the amount wholly stolen

Period: 2014-04-28

Putting the amount in context

About 8.5 times

the original contract value by December 2010

A project cost above $620 million was about 8.5 times the original $73 million contract.

What this comparison means: The comparison shows cost growth, not the amount of fraud. The project and the original contract do not have identical scope.

How we calculated this and where it comes from

$620M / $73M

Contract growth is not a calculation of fraud. Different time and scope make this a historical cost-growth comparison, not a unit-efficiency measure. Round to 'about 8.5×', not 'more than 8.5×'.

What actually happened?

The case established kickbacks, inflated labor rates, overstaffing and false timesheets. A 2014 release reported more than $466 million in restitution paid to the city and $40 million in cancelled debt.

Keep in mind: Project costs, stolen money, repayments and cancelled debt can overlap and must not be added as separate losses.

Read the detailed findings

CityTime's prime contract was about $73 million in 2000; project costs reached over $620 million by the arrests. DOJ established kickbacks, inflated labor rates, overstaffing and false timesheets. Its release reports substantial recoveries.

Reported status: Three scheme leaders were sentenced in 2014. DOJ reported over $466 million restitution paid to the city and $40 million in debt canceled.

Project cost, proven fraud loss, restitution, forfeiture and canceled debt are different measures that may overlap.

Can we follow the payments?

A report can tell us the total. To follow the money, we also need to connect each bill to a payment and to what was received.

Payment records and reporting periods · reviewed November 9, 2026

What could a 3-month funding checkpoint have changed?

Trace the money that went out after a checkpoint. The Receipts Act could require independent progress approval before the next funding release.

Gross payments potentially stopped under these assumptions$81,715,573 – $98,997,876

Assumes review could prevent 100% of later spending. This includes payments for real work. Actual savings depend on which costs were avoidable, contract obligations, recoveries and assets kept.

CityTime contract payments ↗

Checkbook NYC rows for SAIC contract CT113120040003544, issued February 16–October 27, 2010. Matched using the vendor, payroll agency, contract and TIME capital-project codes.

Start of the registered contract
Aug 13, 2003
Funding checkpoint
Nov 13, 2003
Cash spending definitely after it
$81,715,573
Repeated rows awaiting reconciliation
Up to $17,282,303

100 distinct visible payment rows · 15 repeated rows remain uncertain

Inspect the amounts, scope and source documents

115 source rows total $98,997,876.22. Counting one copy of each identical visible row gives $81,715,573.22. Fifteen repeated rows account for $17,282,303.00. Without the missing accounting-line identifiers, that difference stays in the upper bound.

These are accounting lines grouped under 25 payment-document identifiers. They are not 115 separate checks. Repeated visible rows may represent separate allocations or duplicate export rows.

The registered contract begins in August 2003. The collected payment records begin in February 2010, so earlier payments remain absent.

The contract match uses the SAIC vendor, Office of Payroll Administration, contract amount and TIME capital-project codes. The exported purpose only describes amendment 11.

The September 2010 audit is a documented checkpoint. Earlier concerns existed. All collected payment dates end before a three-month delay after that audit.

Payments include delivered payroll-system work. Restitution, penalties, releases and the cost of useful work have not been reconciled with these particular lines.

Payment dates and reporting periods
RecordPayment date or reporting windowIncluded amountUnresolved amount
Checkbook payment linesFeb 16, 2010$4,958,029$0
Checkbook payment linesMar 1, 2010$720,208$0
Checkbook payment linesMar 8, 2010$10,838$0
Checkbook payment linesMar 15, 2010$7,902,865$3,191,204
Checkbook payment linesMar 30, 2010$2,359,613$0
Checkbook payment linesMay 5, 2010$482,173$482,173
Checkbook payment linesMay 18, 2010$1,506,773$213,010
Checkbook payment linesJun 7, 2010$1,224$0
Checkbook payment linesJun 16, 2010$868,978$0
Checkbook payment linesJun 21, 2010$260,106$0
Checkbook payment linesJun 30, 2010$13,631,342$5,937,054
Checkbook payment linesJul 6, 2010$549,252$244,112
Checkbook payment linesJul 13, 2010$1,177,472$0
Checkbook payment linesJul 21, 2010$14,490,708$0
Checkbook payment linesAug 4, 2010$106,891$0
Checkbook payment linesAug 9, 2010$120,522$0
Checkbook payment linesAug 30, 2010$635,449$0
Checkbook payment linesSep 27, 2010$299,344$0
Checkbook payment linesOct 4, 2010$5,504,395$0
Checkbook payment linesOct 18, 2010$7,192,692$0
Checkbook payment linesOct 19, 2010$269,882$0
Checkbook payment linesOct 20, 2010$1,004$0
Checkbook payment linesOct 25, 2010$1,670,783$0
Checkbook payment linesOct 27, 2010$16,995,031$7,214,750
  • $4,668,611 · Oct 4, 2010SCIENCE APPLICATIONS INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION · Contract CT113120040003544 · 20110094591-1-DSB-EFT
  • $3,569,445 · Oct 27, 2010SCIENCE APPLICATIONS INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION · Contract CT113120040003544 · 20110118657-1-DSB-EFT
  • $3,432,311 · Jun 30, 2010SCIENCE APPLICATIONS INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION · Contract CT113120040003544 · 20100182883-1-DSB-EFT

The lower amount uses records entirely after the checkpoint, counting indistinguishable repeated rows once. The upper amount also includes periods crossing the checkpoint and unresolved repeated rows. Amounts are never spread evenly across unknown payment dates. Missing records remain outside the total. The selected review date may be later than the first warning.

Payment-record search · Payment dates added

Checkbook NYC rows for SAIC contract CT113120040003544, issued February 16–October 27, 2010. Matched using the vendor, payroll agency, contract and TIME capital-project codes. 115 source rows total $98,997,876.22. Counting one copy of each identical visible row gives $81,715,573.22. Fifteen repeated rows account for $17,282,303.00. Without the missing accounting-line identifiers, that difference stays in the upper bound.

Still needed Reconcile the 15 repeated visible rows using accounting-line identifiers. Obtain earlier CityTime payments and match recoveries and delivered work to this contract.

Reviewed November 9, 2026

Complete invoice-to-payment links

Whole amount shownOver $620 million project cost
Invoice
What was charged.
Payment record
What was paid.
Delivery record
What was received.
0% traced to invoices and payments in this file0% of the stated Over $620 million project cost is linked here to an invoice and payment record. $0 is linked to invoices and payments; $0 also has delivery acceptance. $620,000,000 has no matched invoice and payment in this case file.

Invoice + payment record

$0 linked here

No matching invoice and payment records have been added to this file.

The circle shows the share of the displayed total with those records. Blue means linked here; gray means not linked here.

0% means no matching records are linked in this file. It does not describe every record the government holds or prove that money was lost or stolen.

Help make invoices, payments and proof of delivery public.

Support the Receipts Act
How this is measured and which records are linked

This file currently links summary-level sources, with no itemized invoice-to-payment records registered against this amount. The pie measures this collection only. Project cost by December 2010, partly driven by fraud; not the amount wholly stolen. Preserve the source qualifier: this is not an exact spending denominator.

Only invoice and payment records tied to this same amount and scope count. Delivery coverage also requires a linked acceptance record. A report showing a total does not count as an individual receipt.

Invoice, payment and delivery linked
$0
Invoice and payment linked; delivery not linked
$0
No matched invoice and payment in this file
$620,000,000

0 matching invoice/payment records; 0 also link to delivery.

No individual invoice-to-payment records are registered in this file yet. This does not establish that those records do not exist elsewhere.

What is still missing?

Which paid hours and contract changes produced working features, and how do recoveries compare with proven losses?

Which records would help answer this?

The linked prosecution summary does not reconcile every contract amendment, approved hour, invoice, delivered system feature and recovery. A reader cannot derive a project-wide verified-deliverable percentage from it.

  • Link contract amendments, rate schedules and invoices to approved timesheets and accepted software milestones.
  • Publish subcontractor ownership, conflicts disclosures and sole-source justifications.
  • Reconcile restitution, forfeiture and canceled debt without double counting.

These records have not all been assembled here. They may exist elsewhere. Personal details should stay protected.

Can we estimate how much was wasted or stolen?

This file does not establish an independent value for everything delivered. Subtracting a guessed value from a headline amount would not establish fraud. A sound estimate needs matching costs, delivered results and evidence about why any money was lost.

Sources and research notes (6 documents)

These documents support the case. A source document can describe many payments; it is not itself an itemized receipt.

  1. DOJ: Three Leaders of CityTime Fraud Scheme Sentenced to 20 Years

    justice.gov · 2014-04-28

  2. DOJ CityTime recovery and amount paid to SAIC

    justice.gov · Reviewed 2026-11-09

  3. SAIC deferred-prosecution agreement

    justice.gov · Reviewed 2026-11-09

  4. Checkbook NYC contract and dated payment search

    checkbooknyc.com · Reviewed 2026-11-09

  5. Archived Checkbook export, all 115 original rows

    impactline.org · Reviewed 2026-11-09

  6. Comptroller CityTime oversight audit

    comptroller.nyc.gov · Reviewed 2026-11-09

Research cutoff: November 9, 2026. Older reports may not include later changes. Read our methodology.